Capital gains can feel like a mystery until you break them down with real numbers. In both the U.S. and Canada, you buy an asset, it rises in value, you sell, and you owe tax on the profit.
But the way each country calculates, exempts, and allows losses on those gains can produce very different results.
This guide pulls the most practical points together for investors and homeowners who want to stay ahead of the tax curve.
A Quick Look
Capital Gains Rate Mechanics
View this post on Instagram
Capital gains rates in the U.S. and Canada look similar at first glance, but the mechanics behind them work very differently.
A quick look at how each system calculates the taxable portion of a gain sets the stage for everything that follows.
U.S. Rate Bands Plus a Surtax for High Investment Income
According to the IRS, long-term capital gains enjoy preferential federal rates of 0, 15, or 20 percent depending on your taxable income. Short-term gains are taxed as ordinary income at your marginal rate.
If your investment income exceeds certain thresholds, an additional 3.8 percent Net Investment Income Tax (NIIT) applies.
A practical way to think about it:
- If taxable income is low, a long-term stock gain may fall into the 0 percent bracket.
- Middle incomes often see 15 percent on long term gains.
- Very high incomes push part of the gain into 20 percent, and NIIT can add another 3.8 percent.
The IRS publishes annual thresholds so you can check exactly where you stand before you sell.
Canada’s Inclusion Rate System with a Pending Change
Canada has no special capital gains rates. Instead, a portion of the gain is included in income and taxed at your marginal rate. Currently, the inclusion rate is one half.
Canada Government reported that in 2024, the federal government announced a move to two thirds inclusion for corporations and trusts and for individuals above a 250,000 CAD annual gains threshold, but deferred the start to January 1, 2026. For now, you include one half of the gain in income.
For very large gains, this deferred change could affect planning. Investors with gains near the 250,000 CAD mark may find timing matters around late 2025.
Home Sale Relief Compared
Selling a home can trigger a tax bill, but both countries offer ways to soften the blow. Let’s take a look at how each system shields a portion, or sometimes all, of the gain when you sell your primary residence.
U.S. Principal Home – Section 121 Exclusion
If you owned and used your main home for at least two years during the five years before the sale, you can exclude up to 250,000 USD of gain if single or up to 500,000 USD if married filing jointly.
You generally cannot claim the exclusion more than once every two years. Partial exclusions are allowed for specific life events such as job changes or health issues.
Key Checkpoints
- Meet both the ownership and use tests within the five-year window.
- Keep thorough records of basis adjustments such as improvements and selling costs.
- The exclusion does not apply to rental or business property unless reconverted to your main home and still qualifying.
Canada Principal Residence Exemption and the Flipping Rule
Canada’s principal residence exemption can shelter or eliminate the taxable portion of a gain on your home for the years you designate it as your principal residence. Since 2016, reporting the sale on your tax return is mandatory to claim the exemption.
The CRA explains designation rules, eligible property types, and limits on land size and mixed-use situations.
Important Updates
- Forgetting to report can lead to penalties and the need to amend your return.
- A federal residential property flipping rule applies to dispositions on or after January 1, 2023. Selling a housing unit within 365 days of acquisition means the profit is deemed business income and fully taxable. No principal residence exemption is allowed unless you meet specific exceptions such as death, disability, separation, or job relocation.
- Provinces can layer on their own rules, such as British Columbia’s Home Flipping Tax starting at 20 percent if sold within 365 days and tapering off by 730 days.
Loss Treatment and Anti-Avoidance Rules
Capital gains aren’t just about profits: how you handle losses and avoid missteps can shape your tax bill just as much.
In both countries, special rules determine when losses count, when they’re denied, and how far you can carry them.
U.S. Offset and Wash Sale Rule
Capital losses first offset capital gains. If losses exceed gains, up to 3,000 USD of net capital loss can reduce ordinary income in the current year, with unused losses carried forward indefinitely.
The wash sale rule disallows a loss if you buy the same or substantially identical security within 30 days before or after the sale. The disallowed loss adds to the basis of the new shares. This rule applies to securities, options, many funds, and certain REMIC interests.
Digital assets present a nuance. The IRS treats virtual currency as property, but current wash sale law references stock or securities. While many believe crypto wash sales are not captured under the statute, proposals have circulated to change this. Documentation is crucial.
Canada’s Superficial Loss Rule and Flipped Property Loss
In Canada, allowable capital losses can only offset taxable capital gains. Net capital losses may be carried back three years or forward indefinitely to offset taxable capital gains in those years.
The superficial loss rule denies a loss if you or an affiliated person acquires the same or identical property during the period beginning 30 days before and ending 30 days after the disposition, and the property is still held 30 days after.
Affiliated person includes your spouse or common-law partner and certain corporations or trusts you control.
Under the federal flipping rule, if a property sale within 365 days is deemed business income, any loss is deemed nil. You cannot create a business loss by flipping at a loss.
Canadian investors often watch more than markets; lifestyle sites like MapleCasino show how provincial regulations vary in other sectors too.
Worked Examples
Nothing beats seeing the rules in action. The scenarios below show how U.S. and Canadian capital gains rules play out with real numbers, making the differences easy to spot at a glance.
Example A – Selling Stock with a Gain
U.S.: A single filer with 50,000 USD of wages realizes a 20,000 USD long term stock gain. Depending on total taxable income after deductions, the gain is taxed at 15 percent or potentially 0 percent.
If the filer crosses into NIIT territory, an extra 3.8 percent applies on net investment income over the threshold.
Canada: A resident realizes a 20,000 CAD gain on stock in 2025. With the one half inclusion rate before 2026, 10,000 CAD is included in income and taxed at marginal rates.
If the investor waits until 2026 and the two thirds inclusion applies above 250,000 CAD for individuals, only the portion above that threshold would be included at two thirds.
Example B – Harvesting Losses in December
U.S.: You sell Fund A for a 5,000 USD loss on December 10 and immediately buy the same ticker on December 15. That is a wash sale. The 5,000 USD loss is disallowed this year and added to the basis of the new shares. Waiting at least 31 days keeps the loss deductible.
Canada: You sell ETF B for a 5,000 CAD loss on December 10, and your spouse buys an identical ETF on December 20 and still owns it on January 9.
Example C: Selling Your Main Home
U.S.: A married couple bought a house for 400,000 USD and sold it for 950,000 USD after three years. Selling expenses and qualified improvements total 50,000 USD. The gain is 500,000 USD.
The Section 121 exclusion allows up to 500,000 USD for married filing jointly if the tests are met, so there may be zero taxable gain.
Canada: A couple sells their principal residence with a 500,000 CAD gain. They lived in it each year since purchase, never designated another home for those years, and reported the sale.
The principal residence exemption can fully shelter the gain if designation conditions are met and the property is not captured by the flipping rule.
Planning Pointers for Investors
- Mind the 61-day window. In both countries, the critical period is 30 days before to 30 days after the sale. Coordinate trades across all accounts in the household.
- Carryovers matter. Americans can apply up to 3,000 USD against ordinary income each year and carry the rest forward indefinitely. Canadians can carry net capital losses back three years or forward indefinitely but only against taxable capital gains.
- Watch inclusion rate timing. Canadian residents with large planned dispositions should monitor Department of Finance updates around the deferred 2026 start for the two thirds inclusion on amounts above 250,000 CAD.
- Digital assets are tricky. In the U.S., digital assets are taxed as property. The wash sale statute references stock and securities, creating a grey zone. Keep detailed records.
Planning Pointers for Homeowners
- Keep records. Americans should maintain improvement receipts, property tax assessments, and closing costs. The Section 121 worksheets in IRS Publication 523 help walk through adjustments.
- Report your Canadian home sale. Even when fully sheltered by the principal residence exemption, reporting is required for 2016 and later years.
- Factor in flipping rules. In Canada, selling within 365 days may reclassify the profit as business income and deny the exemption. Provinces add their own flipping taxes with separate rate scales.
- Check state taxes. Some U.S. states have no personal income tax, while others tax capital gains as ordinary income. Washington imposes a separate 7 percent capital gains excise tax on large long-term gains, as per the Tax Foundation.
Side-by-Side Checklist Before Selling Investments
Before you lock in a gain or a loss, it helps to pause and run through a quick set of checks. The list below highlights the key points investors in both countries should review before making a sale.
U.S.
- Identify positions with long term gains versus short term.
- Estimate federal impact at 0, 15, or 20 percent plus NIIT if applicable.
- Review state rules.
- Schedule loss harvesting well outside the 30-day wash sale window.
Canada
- Tally net gains and losses for inclusion.
- Confirm superficial loss risk across your own and affiliated accounts.
- Consider the deferral of the two thirds inclusion until 2026 for large dispositions.
Side-by-Side Checklist Before Selling Your Home
Selling a home can feel routine until the paperwork hits. A quick checklist puts the key tests, records, and deadlines right in front of you so nothing important slips through.
U.S.
- Confirm you meet the two-out-of-five ownership and use tests.
- Gather records for basis adjustments.
- Review Publication 523 worksheets.
Canada
- Confirm which years you will designate the property as your principal residence.
- Prepare to report the sale on the return.
- Check whether the 365-day flipping rule could apply and whether any provincial flipping tax is in play.
FAQs
Final Takeaways
Think in layers. In the U.S., start by determining whether your gain is long term or short term, then check your income band and the NIIT threshold, and finally layer on your state’s rules.
In Canada, start with inclusion rate and timing, then check the principal residence exemption rules or loss rules, and finally look at any provincial measures that could add a second tax.
Keep airtight records. Basis, improvements, holding periods, and who bought what within the 61-day windows can make or break an outcome.
Watch the calendar. The Canadian inclusion rate deferral to January 1, 2026 and the flipping rule timelines both make dates matter. Americans also benefit from carefully timing sales to keep gains within lower bands and to avoid wash sales.
