After a long pause during the pandemic, student loan collections in the U.S. are officially resuming. For millions of borrowers, it’s a financial hit with ripple effects that could last decades.
Student debt isn’t just about individual choices or college costs. It’s about race, wealth, history, and how the system keeps some people behind while others get to leap ahead. As collections restart, the cracks in the system are only getting more visible, especially for Black and Latinx borrowers who are already carrying the heaviest loads. Let’s break it down.
Key Stats
| Metric | Value |
| Wealth Ratio (White vs. Black Families) | 10x more |
| Wealth Ratio (White vs. Black College Grads) | 7x more |
| Avg. Black Grad Debt (4 Years Out) | $52,726 |
| Avg. White Grad Debt (4 Years Out) | $28,006 |
| Black Borrowers with Growing Loan Balances | Nearly 75% |
| Annual Economic Drain from Collections | $85.48 billion |
The Debt Is Not Distributed Equally
Not all debt is created or distributed equally. 86% of Black students borrow for college, compared to 68% of white students (as per Bankrate) The Education Data Initiative reports that Black bachelor’s degree holders have an average of $52,726 in student loan debt, while white graduates owe $28,006.
Four years after graduation, that gap explodes: $52,726 vs. $28,006. That’s not just a few thousand dollars here or there; it’s a massive difference in starting lines, and it traces back to something deeper: family wealth.
The average white family has about 10 times the wealth of the average Black family. According to the U.S. Census Bureau’s 2021 data, households with a White, non-Hispanic householder had a median wealth of $250,400, while those with a Black householder had a median wealth of $24,520.
Mean (Average) Wealth
Mean wealth figures are more heavily influenced by households with the greatest amounts of wealth. According to Brookings, in 2019, White households reported average wealth of $983,400, which was 6.9 times that of Black households at $142,500.
By 2022, the average wealth of White families had increased to $1.4 million, while that of Black families was $211,596, making White families’ average wealth more than six times higher, as per Urban Institute.
The Wealth Building Struggle
Let’s talk about what student debt actually blocks. It’s not just a monthly payment. It’s delayed dreams:
- Buying a first home
- Starting a business
- Saving for retirement
- Even starting a family
For many Black borrowers who already face job market discrimination and lower average wages, those dreams feel even further out of reach. The Roosevelt Institute put a number to it: restarting collections could pull $85.48 billion annually from 18.1 million borrowers. That’s money that’s not going into homes, local businesses, or even basic needs. It’s a drain, and communities of color are losing the most.
The Gap That Keeps Getting Bigger
White college grads have over about 10 times the wealth of Black college grads, according to Urban Institute. That’s a tough pill to swallow, especially when education is supposed to be the “great equalizer”. However, when you’re repaying debt with interest and little family support, the math just doesn’t work out. The system is stacked in a way that:
- Nearly 75% of Black borrowers now owe more than they originally took out.
- Meanwhile, white borrowers are more likely to pay down debt quickly thanks to higher incomes and family assistance.
Even income-driven repayment plans, meant to ease the pressure, often end up growing the debt due to interest. It’s a trap, and people are stuck in it for decades.
Mental Health Matters
Financial stress isn’t just about numbers; it’s deeply emotional. In Canada, platforms like My Canada Payday aim to alleviate short-term financial burdens through quick loan services. These platforms and institutions can help people relieve some stress. This is very important because, according to the 2022 study conducted by ELVTR:
- 56% feel anxiety
- 32% struggle with depression
- 20% report insomnia
- 17% experience panic symptoms
On top of that, 80% of borrowers are delaying life milestones like getting married, buying a home, or having kids, all of which have long-term effects on financial stability. Black borrowers bear a disproportionate share of that emotional and psychological burden.
The Family Ripple Effect
Whole families are stretched because of student debt. Black parents are more likely to borrow to put their kids through college. That adds another layer of strain, one that white families, with more generational wealth, are better positioned to avoid. This kind of debt creates a loop: parents borrow for their kids, then can’t save for retirement. Kids graduate with debt and can’t help their parents, and the cycle repeats.
The Policy Problem
The Biden administration’s plan (canceling $10,000 for borrowers under $125k and an extra $10,000 for Pell Grant recipients) sounds nice, but the numbers tell a different story:
- 60% of the relief would go to white borrowers.
- Only 25% would go to Black borrowers, despite their higher debt loads.
Legal challenges have already blocked broader relief, and the current tax code doesn’t help much either. The $2,500 student loan interest deduction mostly benefits higher-income households, skewing toward white borrowers. Without sweeping reforms, any relief will feel like a drop in the ocean for those most affected.
What Real Reform Could Look Like
View this post on Instagram
If the goal is to close the racial wealth gap and support economic growth, here’s what could help:
1. Broad-Based Debt Cancellation
Canceling $50,000 per borrower could boost Black household wealth by up to 40%, according to the Roosevelt Institute. That’s not charity; it’s economic stimulus.
2. Make Higher Education Affordable
Tuition-free public college isn’t just an idealistic dream. It’s a practical fix to stop future generations from falling into the same debt traps.
3. Revamp Repayment Plans
Interest should be capped, paused, or eliminated for income-driven repayment. Otherwise, borrowers never make real progress.
4. Tax Code Reform
Stop rewarding wealthier borrowers. Target tax relief to those who need it most, not just those who earn enough to deduct interest.
5. Targeted Help for Borrowers of Color
Design programs that directly address the racial debt disparity. That could include grants, targeted forgiveness, or automatic IDR enrollment.
Economic Recovery
Resuming collections now isn’t just about federal revenue, it’s also about timing. With inflation still a factor, wages stagnant for many, and economic inequality at record highs, draining $85 billion out of borrowers’ pockets is a bad bet.
That money could be stimulating the economy, funding small businesses, paying rent, or putting food on the table. It’s communities of color that stand to lose the most. Debt cancellation isn’t just a moral issue; it’s a recovery strategy.
Final Thoughts
Student loans weren’t supposed to be a life sentence, but for millions, they’ve become just that, especially for Black and Latinx borrowers. Restarting collections without fixing the root problems means doubling down on a broken system. It’s not just unfair; it’s damaging, and it’s deeply tied to how wealth (and opportunity) are distributed in America.
If we’re serious about closing the racial wealth gap and building a healthier economy, we can’t go back to business as usual. We need bold, honest solutions that actually meet people where they are, and give them a real shot at getting ahead. Debt should never be the reason someone can’t build a life.
